Image of the glider from the Game of Life by John Conway
Skip to content

Entropy As A Service

Back in October 2012, I announced It's an "entropy server" that delivers encrypted random bits that are indistinguishable from true random, directly to your GNU/Linux input entropy pool. Per the Linux CSPRNG source code, the bits in the input entropy pool are then cryptographically hashed with SHA1 before sending the bits to the blocking and non-blocking pools. The bits generated by my entropy server come only from 5 Entropy Keys, which appear to no longer be in production. I'm working on a "version 2.0" of the server, where more true random sources will be mixed into the pool, such as the onboard Broadcom HWRNG, atmospheric noise, haveged(8), and 2 TrueRNG HWRNGs. Keep an eye out both on this blog, and the entropy server web page for updates.

However, it appears that I am not the only one who has thought of this idea.

In September 2013, the U.S. National Institude of Standards and Technology introduced the NIST Randomness Beacon. Every 60 seconds, a random number is "broadcast", which is cryptographically signed, timestamped, and contains the value of the random number from the previous minute's broadcast. It comes complete with a REST API, which you can take advantage of for your internal application. They warn, very strictly, that these bits should not be used for cryptographic keys. Instead, it would be more fitting to use these random bits as for things such as lottery drawings, dice rolls, and other non-sensitive randomness implementations. However, you could write a REST application that took this data, and reseeded the Linux CSPRNG every 60 seconds. Because SHA1 is only theoretically broken, and not practically broken, and further because the Linux kernel is receiving other sources of input to reseed the CSPRNG, it seems difficult for an attacker to recover the internal state of your CSPRNG without compromising the computer, to determine the sequence of the CSPRNG. A simple shell script could be something like this (assuming you have rhash(1) installed):

# Reseed the Linux kernel CSPRNG with data from NIST
SALT=$(dd if=/dev/urandom bs=64 count=1 2> /dev/null)
EPOCH=$(date --date="$(date +%H:%M:00)" +%s)
DATA=$(echo "${SALT}${RESULTS}" | rhash --sha3-512 - | cut -d ' ' -f 1)
echo "$DATA" > /dev/random

Further, in February 2014, Canonical announced Canonical is providing their own application, which currently seems to be only packaged for Ubuntu, called pollinate. The idea is for newly created Ubuntu VMs or containers to immediately have a source of entropy to rely on, to quickly feed the Linux CSPRNG before it is needed in generating cryptographic keys, such as SSH or SSL keys. Whlie some criticize its security, it seems more like FUD from those who don't fully understand the internal workings of the Linux kernel CSRNG, than actual security concerns. Reseeding the CSPRNG is less of an issue for me, as much as Canonical tracking which IP requested bits from their server, and logging them (as should be the case for any service from any provider). It may be true that on first boot, not enough entropy may have been generated to seed the CSPRNG. As such, initiating a TLS session to a server may open the network connection up for an attack. While the theory might be sound, I would like to see a proof of concept or even an implementation of the attack, before I start FUD slinging.

So, as it sits, there are to my knowledge, three Entropy-as-a-Service (EaaS) servers online, each with different implementations, that require different software, that you could use for a variety of applications. Of course, there is also which has been on the Internet for a good long while, long before "as a service" was a buzz term. However, I don't see them as an entropy server as much as an implementation server. They are great for getting dice rolls, lottery picks, card shuffles, etc, but not so much "raw data", even though it does have a "random number sequence" generator, and it does provide an API.

With the revelations about the NSA and the increasing weight put on cryptography as a result, I'm guessing more of these types of servers will pop up. Also, only my service, so far, actually increases your entropy estimate in your kernel. The other services mentioned here only reseed the Linux kernel CSPRNG, without increasing the entropy estimate.

{ 3 } Comments

  1. Fred | July 23, 2014 at 4:06 pm | Permalink

    What are your thoughts on the hotbits service ( which generates randomness from radioactive decay.
    I didn't see an API for it however.

  2. Aaron Toponce | July 24, 2014 at 7:39 am | Permalink

    Interesting. I didn't know this existed. I guess I could add it to the list, but it looks like as a client, you would need to write a screen scraper to fill out the form, and get the bits. So, unless someone writes such a client, I doubt it will get a lot of use.

    Radioactive decay is definitely a way of getting to quantum random events, but I have found that they are very slow generators. By comparison, my RTL-SDR listening to atmospheric noise can do about 6 Mbps, compared to radioactive decay, which processes about 100 bps per source.

  3. Jack Zielke | October 24, 2014 at 6:35 pm | Permalink

    I was not able to get my hands on one of those entropy keys before they stopped making them. I am using one of those cheap sdr dongles and with rngd to keep my entropy pool full.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared.